The Premiership will not be adopting any of World Rugby’s law trials designed to reduce the risk of coronavirus transmission, the Guardian understands. The law trials, announced by World Rugby on Thursday, include eliminating reset scrums and choke tackles, the introduction of an “orange card” for high tackles and reducing the “use it” time from five seconds to three.
All the trials, which are optional, are designed to reduce the risk of transmission among players by bringing down contact in rucks, scrums and mauls by 25-50%. The trials come after a study by World Rugby’s medical experts but adopting them will be at the discretion of each union. The New Zealand union has already said that it will not be adopting them when Super Rugby Aotearoa begins next month and while the Premiership would need approval from the Rugby Football Union it does not intend to seek it.
A Premiership Rugby spokesperson said: “We are undertaking a review of all aspects of the game to ensure the safe return of Gallagher Premiership Rugby, but don’t anticipate any law changes.”
The Premiership still does not have a return date with clubs not yet cleared to return to training in any form despite government guidelines saying that they can. It is hoped that progress will be at meeting with PRL the RFU and the Rugby Players’ Association on Thursday but despite fears remaining over player safety and concerns over testing procedures, there is no appetite to introduce World Rugby’s law trials.
World Rugby says that the trials are entirely optional and while unions can apply to implement one, some or all of them at either elite or community level, they are more likely to be adopted in the latter. The RFU however, says it is conducting its own research for the community game in England which could include measures not raised by World Rugby.
“The RFU recognises the work World Rugby has done on temporary law trials,” said a spokesperson. “The RFU has its own review underway looking at the options for return to training and return to play rugby for clubs in England. When government advice on social distancing measures are lifted, specific RFU guidance will be announced and provided to clubs.”
With regards to the scrum, as well as doing away with resets, the proposed changes include no scrum option from a penalty or a free-kick, a goal-line drop-out when an attacking players is held up over the try-line and that hookers must use a “brake foot” to aid scrum stability. The sanction for not doing so would be a free-kick.
For high tackles, an orange card would lead to the offending player being removed and, following the use of HawkEye and consultation with the TMO it would either be upgraded to a red card or a penalty or yellow card, which would mean 15 minutes off the pitch. The World Rugby study found that eliminating upright front-on-front tackles would “decrease the frequency of high-risk exposure events by 20%”.
The two proposals for the maul are that no one can join if they are not in the maul from the start and that there can be only one forward movement. Sanctions for both would be a free-kick. At the ruck, as well as reducing the “use it” time, there would be no scrum for infringing the “use it” rule, instead a free-kick would be awarded.